- 18 November 2026
Cape Town, March 2018. Australia and South Africa were locked at 1-1 in a fiercely contested Test series with the hosts building a commanding lead on the third afternoon of the third Test. Then, in a matter of seconds, TV cameras caught Australian opener Cameron Bancroft appearing to use sandpaper to alter the condition of the ball - an incident that immediately overshadowed the cricket itself.
The renewed debate around Sandpapergate offers an opportunity to look beyond the question of sportsmanship and towards stewardship.
Who knew about the ball-tampering scheme is ultimately a matter for cricket historians and investigators. The governance question is different: how could such an incident occur within a high-performing national sporting organisation, and why was the initial investigation unable to uncover a shared truth?
When misconduct becomes a governance issue
The latest claims - and counterclaims - surrounding the incident centre on a familiar question. Was the plot known only to a small group of players, or was awareness more widespread within the Australian team and staff?
From a governance perspective, the key concern is whether the Australian cricket team environment had effective systems of accountability, oversight and reporting. When serious misconduct occurs and there is no universally agreed narrative, governance professionals naturally begin asking questions.
The number of conflicting accounts is particularly eye-opening, if not necessarily surprising. Retired Australian opener Usman Khawaja released his autobiography this month, implicating the entire team in the scandal. Current captain Pat Cummins followed this up with a lengthy press conference in which he described this version of events as “utter nonsense.” Batter Cameron Bancroft, who served a nine-month ban from the sport for his role in 2018, penned his own 4,000 word “tell-all” explanation, in which he backed Khawaja’s claims that acceptance and support of the cheating spanned from the players to the backroom staff – with the exception of media manager Kate Hutchison. Despite her unease, there were not proper or robust channels available for her to blow the whistle, so her concerns were raised only within dressing room discussions, rather than escalated further.
In well-governed organisations, major failures are typically followed by a credible investigation, clearly established accountability and a broadly accepted understanding of what occurred. When competing narratives continue years later, it inevitably raises questions about transparency, culture and organisational learning, alongside a lack of sanctions and remedial action.
These questions apply as relevantly in sport as they do in the boardroom.
Notes on a corporate scandal
The governance themes within Sandpapergate are strikingly similar to those seen in major corporate scandals.
In the 2015 Volkswagen “diesel dupe”, the key issue was not who programmed the software designed to defeat emissions tests, but how organisational pressures and leadership behaviours allowed the misconduct to develop and remain unchallenged.
Similarly, the Wells Fargo fake accounts debacle of the 2010’s was not fundamentally about individual employees opening unauthorised accounts. Investigations focused on the incentive structures, management culture and weak oversight that encouraged unethical behaviour.
The same pattern emerged in cases such as FIFA's ongoing corruption scandal and the UK's Post Office Horizon affair. In each instance, governance failures proved more consequential than the original acts of misconduct because they revealed systemic weaknesses in accountability, reporting and culture.
High-performance environments often create intense pressure to deliver results, and sport is no different. Without a culture of accountability and trusted, publicised and confidential mechanisms for raising concerns - coupled with the knowledge that they will be acted upon - that pressure can distort decision-making, weaken ethical judgement and prevent individuals from speaking up.
Culture is where governance becomes visible
Malpractice rarely exists in isolation, and yet Sandpapergate was originally framed as a question of individual culpability.
A player using sandpaper to tamper with a ball is an act of misconduct. Perverse incentives and cultures that normalise excessive win-at-all-costs behaviour, discourage challenge or create ambiguity around acceptable conduct are a governance issue.
The most effective organisations do not simply ask who broke the rules. They ask what factors made the breach possible and what changes are required to prevent a recurrence.
Leadership failure, governance failure, or both?
A leadership failure occurs when individuals in positions of authority exercise poor judgement or create an unhealthy environment. A governance failure occurs when organisational systems fail to prevent, detect or respond effectively to those shortcomings.
In practice, serious organisational crises frequently involve both.
If senior figures encouraged, tolerated, or were actively involved in unethical behaviour – which several of the outspoken players claim - that reflects a leadership issue. If oversight mechanisms failed to identify cultural risks, clarify accountability or establish a trusted account of events, that points to a governance issue.
Strong governance should not depend on the judgement of a handful of leaders. It should create safeguards that continue to function when those leaders make mistakes.
Why the debate still matters
For governance professionals, the issue is more nuanced than whether every player knew. The more important question is whether Cricket Australia’s systems of accountability, oversight and culture were capable of preventing the incident, uncovering the full truth and restoring confidence afterwards.
Viewed through that lens, Sandpapergate is not just a sporting scandal, but a case study in governance, and the continuing debate serves as a reminder that the most significant organisational failures are rarely the result of a single poor decision.
Interested in learning more about sports governance and how to prevent conflicts in your organisation? Register for our Level 4 Certificate in Sports Governance before 30 November and save 30% off course fees.
